EFFECT OF BUSINESS EDUCATION PROGRAM ON ENTREPRENEURIAL ABILITIES OF COLLEGES OF EDUCATION GRADUATES IN NORTH-CENTRAL ZONE, NIGERIA  

ABSTRACT

The study was conducted to establish the Influence of Business Education Curriculum on

Entrepreneurial Skills of Colleges of Education Graduates in North-central Zone of Nigeria. The study was necessitated by the continuous decline of colleges of education business education graduates’ entrepreneurial skills which has resulted into escalating unemployment, social vices and economic hardship amongst others. The study had six objectives. Six research questions were generated to guide the study and six null hypotheses were formulated and tested at 0.05 level of significance. Survey research design was used in the study. The population of the study was one hundred and forty four (144), made up of sixty (60) business education graduates (entrepreneurs) and eighty four (84) of their employees. The entire population was used in the study. Two sets of questionnaire were developed and used for data collection. The administration of the instrument took four weeks. One hundred and four (104) copies of the questionnaire were completed and returned. In answering the research questions, weighted mean of 2.5 and above was used as benchmark for agree while weighted mean of less than 2.5 represented disagree. Regression Analysis was used to test hypotheses 1,2,3,4 and 5 while t-test was used to test hypothesis 6, all at 0.05 level of significance. Null hypothesis one was rejected while Null hypotheses two, three, four and five were retained. The study revealed among others that business education curriculum has no significant influence on financial management skills of colleges of education graduates. Also, it was revealed that business education curriculum has no significant influence on innovative skills of colleges of education graduates.  Therefore, the researcher concludes that business education curriculum has little influence on entrepreneurial skills of colleges of education graduates in North-central Zone of Nigeria. This action can result to lack of entrepreneurial skills by graduates of colleges of education to undertake a viable business venture for self-reliance which might result to increase in the level of unemployment, economic hardship and social vices amongst business education graduates. In view of these findings, five recommendations were made among others that business education curriculum should be strengthened by National Commission for Colleges of Education business education curriculum planners to broaden its financial management skill components. Equally, business education curriculum should be reviewed by NCCE business education curriculum planners to ensure adequate incorporation of innovative skill components.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CHAPTER ONE

INTRODUCTION

1.1       Background to the study

Entrepreneurship education is a course of study introduced to equip the recipients with the skills of how to utilize whatever utility skills that they acquired to take advantage of opportunities in an environment in order to become self-reliant. Business education programme of colleges of education provides a study in entrepreneurship skill acquisition to prepare students of the programme for business entrepreneurship. According to Andrea (2010) entrepreneurial skills should consist of five basic skills which include: human resource management skills, financial management skills, innovative skills, customer skills and marketing management skills.

Business education is a programme of study that prepares individuals with multiple skills to teach, or work in industry and to equally set up a business as an entrepreneur and employ others. Ibrahim (2011), has stated that business education is divided into two parts: Office education which is vocational in nature for office careers and general business education which is a programme that provides information and competencies needed for managing businesses. Aliyu (2004) in Ibrahim (2010) defines business education curriculum as planned sequence of formal courses and other activities and learning experiences which a student follows in an attempt to achieve particular educational objectives. It was expected that business education programme provides human resource, financial, innovative, customer and marketing skills.

Entrepreneurship education aims at raising awareness of students about business skills, knowledge, promoting creativity, innovation and self-employment. This includes the acquisition of skills in areas that would be useful and make them self-reliant, and independent productive citizens of the society. Entrepreneurship is critical to the economic development of any nation. An entrepreneur is one who engages in business undertaking with an active and enterprising spirit. An entrepreneur is any person who coordinates the factors of production and bears the risk of uncertainty by investing scarce resources in business ventures. It is necessary for such an individual to acquire skills such as human resource management skills, marketing skills, customer service skills, financial management skills, creative/ innovative skills and risk management skills.

The focus of the study was to systematically investigate and document the influence of business education curriculum on entrepreneurial skills of colleges of education graduates in the North-central Geo-political Zone of Nigeria. The assumption was that there was a positive influence, but where there are challenges and gaps, the study should provide a framework to address these gaps, and make the graduates of business education in the North-central  Zone more self- reliant and better job creators, thereby contributing to national development. North-central Geo-political Zone is one of the six Geo-political zones in Nigeria consisting of six states, namely Benue, Kogi, Kwara, Nassarawa, Niger and Plateau. The zone has three federal and nine state owned colleges of education offering business education.

1.2       Statement of the Problem

Business education is a programme of study that prepares individuals with

multiple skills for teaching and entrepreneurship activities. Ali (2010) states that dearth of employment related skills; entrepreneurial skills and ignorance of the work environment among youths have caused economic and personal hardship within the past few years. With so many graduates in the labour market, employers look for evidence of skills which would make an individual stand out from the crowd. In the last decade there had been growing economic downturn in the country leading to a situation of drop in the capacity of government and corporate organizations to provide employment to graduates of institutions of higher learning. This has been the case with graduates of business education from colleges of education. The situation has led to a paradigm shift from relying on government jobs to the acquisition of entrepreneurial skills for self-reliance. Functional educational programmes, such as effective business education, that is supposed to instill entrepreneurship and job skills for self-sustenance amongst the colleges of education graduates, may have not done much.

Experience of the researcher as a business education lecturer for a decade, interaction with owners of business organizations have pointed to the possibility of business education graduates of colleges of education not having desirable skills for starting, operating and managing their business enterprise. Many employers are known to have complained that NCE business education graduates cannot communicate effectively, write correct letters or memo, provide leadership in the absence of the manager, take initiative, work without supervision, work as a team, keep simple financial records, operate simple office machine, keep proper filling system, cover meetings and take accurate minutes, in addition, they are not creative, not innovative, lack good customer relations, lack marketing skills, lack human resource management skills, lack financial management skills, lack skills to work under pressure and lack maintenance culture. Could these inadequacies be as a result of inadequate NCE business education curriculum content to address these skills gaps?  Could it be that the skills learnt in the classroom are different from what is obtainable in work place? Could it be as a result of lack of basic facilities for acquisition of these basic skills?

Based on the factors and issues emphasized above, there may exist skills gap in the curriculum of NCE business education in colleges of education. Therefore, the focus of the researcher is to systematically investigate and document the influence of business education curriculum on the acquisition of entrepreneurial skills of colleges of education students on their graduation to enable them cope with managing a successful business venture in order be self- reliant in the face of unemployment and economic recession in

Nigeria.

1.3       Objectives of the Study

The general objective of the study is to determine the Influence of Business

Education Curriculum on Entrepreneurial Skills of Colleges of Education Graduates in North –central  Zone, Nigeria.  The specific objectives of the study are to:

1. determine the influence of business education curriculum on human resource management skills of graduates of colleges of education in North-central Zone of Nigeria.
2. assess the influence of business education curriculum on financial management skills of graduates of colleges of education.
3. assess the influence of business education curriculum on innovative skills of graduates of colleges of education.
4. determine the influence of business education curriculum on customer management skills of graduates of colleges of education.
5. determine the influence of business education curriculum on marketing skills of graduates of colleges of education
6. determine the difference between the views of graduates entrepreneurs and their employees on influences of business education curriculum on entrepreneurial skills.

1.4        Research Questions

            The research work provided answers to the following questions:

1. What is the influence of business education curriculum on human resource management skills of graduates of colleges of education in North-central Zone, Nigeria?
2. What is the influence of business education curriculum on financial management skills of graduates of colleges of education?
3. What is the influence of business education curriculum on innovative skills of graduates of colleges of education?
4. What is the influence of business education curriculum on customer management skills of graduates of colleges of education?
5. What is the influence of business education curriculum on marketing skills of graduates of colleges of education?
6. What is the difference between the views of graduates entrepreneurs and their employees on influences of business education curriculum on entrepreneurship

skills? 

1.5        Research Hypotheses

In line with the research questions, the following null hypotheses were

formulated for this study:

1. Business education curriculum has no significant influence on human resource management skills of graduates of colleges of education in North-central Zone of Nigeria.
2. Business education curriculum has no significant influence on financial management skills of graduates of colleges of education.
3. Business education curriculum has no significant influence on innovative skills of graduates of colleges of education.
4. Business education curriculum has no significant influence on customer management skills of graduates of colleges of education.
5. Business education curriculum has no significant influence on marketing skills of graduates of colleges of education.
6. There is no significant difference between the views of graduates entrepreneurs and their employees on influences of business education curriculum on entrepreneurship skills of graduates of colleges of education.

1.6       Significance of the Study

The result of the study will be significantly important in many respects. It will be useful to business education graduates, business education lecturers, students, curriculum planners, state and federal governments, employers of business education graduates, society and other stake-holders in education in the following ways;

The findings of this study will yield relevant data required to strengthen, sustain and expand the entrepreneurial skills of business education graduates of colleges of education in Nigeria. Business education students would benefit from the result of the study as it would lead to designing and re-designing business education curriculum, resulting in a development of more effective business education curriculum that will be used to train them. This would ultimately impact on the quality of business education graduates, thus reducing unemployment, poverty, economic and personal hardship among business education graduates in North-central Zone of Nigeria. Through publications and seminars, the result of the study would be made available to business education graduates. Subsequently, it will help the graduates to appreciate entrepreneurship education and take advantage of business opportunities to set up their own businesses, thereby contributing positively to the development of micro, small and medium scale enterprise to expand national economy.

The result of the study will further provide business education lecturers with appropriate knowledge and skills of instructions and strategies that will enhance teaching and learning. Business education lecturers would enrich their entrepreneurship skills through reading the publication of this work in journals and in seminars.

It will also be of great assistance to the National Commission for Colleges of Education (NCCE), as it will assist the commission to clearly see the relevance of entrepreneurship skills, which would result in developing more effective business education curriculum. Besides, the findings will help the curriculum planners in collecting relevant and reliable data required to support advocacy by various interest groups for better and practical education system that will meet the needs of the graduates and the labour market. Invariably, this would emphasize out the areas of inadequacy that the planner will intervene to address identified skills-gap

The findings of the study will be of great benefit to the state and Federal Ministries of Education as it will reveal the strengths and weaknesses of colleges of education business education programme. The result of the study would encourage government to invest more in business education programme to the benefit of students as new equipments and centers for skills acquisition would be provided. It will help government to formulate appropriate educational policies to justify her heavy investment in education.

The result of the study will motivate employers of business education graduates to collaborate with state, federal government and educational institutions to provide appropriate and required skills in industries or modern world of work.  Furthermore, it will help to harness the possible disparity between the activities within the school system and the work environment.

The society will benefit from the result of this study as the business education graduates are part of the larger society. As the graduates get employed or establish their own businesses, they would contribute to the growth of the country’s economy. Communities where their businesses are located will benefit from their services and the employment opportunities their businesses would have created. Equally, the study will serve as a reference point for scholars and researchers.

1.7        Basic Assumptions of the Study

In the study the following assumptions were made;

• NCE business education curriculum has positive influence on human resource management skills of colleges of education graduates.
• NCE business education curriculum has positive influence on financial management skills of colleges of education graduates
• NCE business education curriculum has positive influence on innovative skills of colleges of education graduates

1.8       Delimitation of the Study

The study concentrated on the Influence of Business Education Curriculum on

Entrepreneurial skills of Colleges of Education Graduates in North-central Zone of Nigeria who are entrepreneurs (managers) and their employees. The study was delimited to business education graduates of colleges of education from 2005 to 2015 operating their own businesses in North- central Zone of Nigeria and the employees of their businesses.  These graduates were those who registered their businesses with state ministry of commerce and industry. These graduates graduated from state and federal colleges of education in the area of study.  These groups of business education graduates had business experiences ranging from one year to ten years. The delimitation was based on the facts that these graduates were directly involved in the business education programme as students and now as entrepreneurs. These employees have been working closely with these graduates entrepreneur, thus capable of providing relevant data for the success of this research work.

The study was delimited to the following variables; human resource management skills, financial management skills, innovative skills, customer management skills and marketing skills of an entrepreneur. The restriction was based on the assumption of the researcher that NCE business education curriculum has significant influence on these

variables.

EFFECT OF BUSINESS EDUCATION PROGRAM ON ENTREPRENEURIAL ABILITIES OF COLLEGES OF EDUCATION GRADUATES IN NORTH-CENTRAL ZONE, NIGERIA  

Sharing is caring!